RESPONDblogs: Why Does Belief in God Make Logical Sense?

roulette

You stroll casually into the Vegas Casino. The bright lights…the banging and rattling of loose change and mechanical slot machines is joined by the general murmur of the folks at the tables.

“Place your bets, please.”

 

Your eye is drawn to the roulette table. A few people are standing there, placing chips on the green felt table covered with numbers set in red and black squares. They are trying to work out the odds that they can predict what the ball will do…which slot will it land on? Which number will win them the most financial return?

 

Crazy as it may seem…people play this game with their own money. Personally I’m just a bit more conservative (or tight…I’m a Scot) with the little money I have! But the lure of winning big bucks by predicting the right number and the right colour is intoxicating to so many.

 

Now – I don’t want to stress us out. I don’t want to worry you. But in a very real sense…ever since the day we were born…a very important game has been in progress. Chips are being placed…decisions made. But the game is NOT roulette and the stakes are much higher than cash. The stakes are MUCH higher. The game is about my own, personal future.

 

We can’t opt out of the game…we can’t withdraw to a safe place and protect our winnings. No – there’s a single…ultimate roll of the wheel facing every single human being who has lived…is living…and will ever live on this planet. That includes us.

 

The good news is that the odds are pretty favourable for us on this particular bet. Much safer than the average Vegas Casino, I suspect. The odds are 50:50 on this ultimate bet. There are only two squares on the green felt table. And each square has some words written within it.

 

god squares

 

Some will say – ah, I’m not interested in this game. I’m walking away from this table. Religion is not my thing. I’m a scientist, don’t you know. I only think about important questions. Others say – ah, there’s not enough evidence for God. When I reach the pearly gates…if he’s there…ill say, “Not enough evidence, sir!”

The dealer smiles.

Your stakes are already on the table – you cannot withdraw them. There is no opting out. You might claim that this question is unimportant…you might grumble about having to make the choice…but your future hinges on the right choice anyway. The dealer calmly places your chips in the “God does NOT exist” box…and prepares to spin the wheel. Hang on – are you sure? You’ve still got time to move the chips to the other box if you want to?

 

Okay – this is just a bit of fun. But my point is a serious one. You and I are making a gamble with our lives right now. Based on our answer to the God question. So how should we place our bet in life…since we find ourselves alive anyway? What is the most sensible choice?

 

Here’s a thought. How about making the choice that guarantees us maximum happiness? That will deliver the maximum benefit to us at the end of the game. Yea – I know the aim of gambling is to predict the outcome…making us a winner. But that’s not what I am talking about. I am saying – choose the square that will deliver maximum happiness WHATEVER the outcome on the spin of the wheel. Make sense?

So which of the two squares delivers us maximum happiness whatever the outcome to the God question?

god_exists

If we place our chips here and the spin of the wheel results in the truth that – actually yes, God DOES exist – then this is great. The Bible says we have the opportunity to gain eternal life and eternal happiness. However – if it transpires that God does NOT exist…then in this bet…our life will end in oblivion anyway so we have lost nothing.

 

god does not

If we place our chips here, but it transpires that God DOES exist…then we have suffered unimaginable loss. We have lost eternity. But if it transpires that God does NOT exist anyway…then we have gained nothing again and oblivion beckons.

 

It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to know which square will result in the maximum happiness for us. It’s the “God exists” square. It’s actually the only choice that leads to happiness and a future, full stop! The odds are 50:50…the dealer is looking at us.

 

Which square do you place your chips?

I’d recommend the “God exists” square. But it’s up to you.

Ok – cross your fingers – now spin the wheel.

 

pascal

What I’ve just done…is given you a simple version of a thought experiment from the Physicist Blaise Pascal  – called “Pascal’s Wager”.

Pascal lived in the 17th century and made enormous contributions to the development of geometry, probability theory, economics and social science. He was also a Christian philosopher. And what he was saying with his famous Wager was simple.

Even if we didn’t have the Bible with all of its recorded guidance, even if we didn’t have 1500 years of Christian church history following the death and resurrection of Christ. (all this evidence weighs the odds heavily in one direction). Even if we had none of that Christian history. As human beings…it would STILL make more sense to build our lives around the decision that “God exists” rather than choosing to live as if “God DOESN’T exist”. Logically…Pascal points out that Theism just makes sense.

 

So where are your chips placed?

 

Advertisements

Published by

stuartgrayuk

I live in the UK, I'm married to Janet and I'm passionate about proposing a case for the historic Christian faith. You can find me on Twitter at @stuhgray.

11 thoughts on “RESPONDblogs: Why Does Belief in God Make Logical Sense?”

  1. Ok, I’ve placed my chips on God exists, but now what? Should I convert to Islam? It offers the best rewards, and threatens the most horrible penalties if I don’t. Why didn’t Pascal convert to Islam?

    1. Hi Paul –

      Why do you jump to Islam? It’s certainly not the oldest belief system, and it does not make the crucial supernatural claims that Christianity does. That God came in person to seek us out. If God exists…he’s already set up the “whole show” of our Universe…don’t you think if he entered our Universe…he would do so in a remarkable way?

      Deciding that God is there – begins to open us up to investigate what he might be like. Definitely worth checking out any claim that he came in person to show us. Any New testament would help there…

      Also – the point about Pascal’s Wager is…that it is viewing life from an eternal perspective…is there an afterlife or isn’t there? If the Islamic terrorists want to send us there more quickly than we’d like…surely they are simply speeding up the process? I’m being facetious with that comment…of course I’m appalled at Islamic violence. But it should not affect one’s decisions where truth and our future is concerned…the important thing is to make the right call now, imho.

      Why didn’t Pascal convert to Islam? Interesting question – how do you plan on investigating that one, Paul? It’s not an unanswerable question. Here’s one approach…you could have a look at his Defense of Christianity that was published after his death. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/18269/18269-h/18269-h.htm

      HTH

      Stu

      1. I jump to Islam because it’s the next logical step of the wager. Or do you think the Christian God has a monopoly on being God? There is a logical problem with Pascal’s wager. God is God but he’s not just the God of the Christians. Pascal just didn’t take the other contenders into consideration. If God exists he’s playing a more confusing game, for he makes us think he has many forms whilst telling us that there is only one true one. If the Casino is in Dubai the answer will be different to one in Texas.

      2. Why do you think Islam is the next logical step of the wager? You’ve just correctly pointed out that Pascal’s Wager makes no claim on the identity OF God…it simply makes a philosophical argument for the existence of a God. So actually NO specific religion is the next logical step. What is…is a journey of discovery of his identity. And an assessment of the evidence.

        There is no logical problem – because Pascal’s Wager as I have laid it out makes no claim that God is the God of the Christians, Paul.

        Now – when you start to look at the evidence for and against the identity OF God…then that’s a different matter entirely. And I would urge you to include Christianity in a spiritual search. But you are right – the Wager doesn’t demand it at all.

        In answer to your question – the God revealed in the Bible is unique amongst all religions…because no other religion presents reasons for a God who loved people enough…that it would cause him to come in person…physically enter his creation and to go looking for them. If you don’t believe me…feel free to compare?

        Stu

      3. But if the wager is, what happens when we die, and you are a Christian and God supports Islam, then you’re going to get some pretty mean treatment whilst the Islamists get all the virgins. So, it would be better to wager on Islam, if what we’re worried about is eternity.
        Remember, in Pascal’s wager, we don’t and can’t know what the result will be, it’s just a question of chance. We just have to choose the best, or in the case of Hell, the least worse possibility.

  2. Who says there is only one God and which God or gods? Pascal wager was dishonestly weighted. What kind of God? Personal or impresonal? Pantheistic or Deistic?
    You see its not nearly as simple as you or pascal make it out to be so please stop parroting his silly wager. It’s not 50 50. You just make us christians look stupid.

    1. How kind – thank you for that – lol.

      Actually Mike…where you place your chips makes a MASSIVE difference on how you live your life. Because when we decide to agree that “God exists”, we are then ready and motivated to investigate and discover what God might actually be like. And if you want to ask the sorts of questions that you blast me with in your kind comment….then go ahead.

      Please don’t put the cart before the horse and misrepresent Pascal’s Wager, sir.

      Stu

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s